How Focused Silver Teaches Kids Not to Compare Themselves to Others

Super Silver Academy is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this page, at no extra cost to you.

Somewhere around five, children start keeping score. They notice who finished the worksheet first, who got the gold star, who can already do a handstand. And then they come home and tell you, quite matter-of-factly, that they're the worst in the class at something. You say it isn't a competition. They look at you as if you have never once been inside a classroom.

They have a point. It very much feels like a competition, and telling a child otherwise asks them to ignore what they can see with their own eyes. The trouble with "don't compare yourself" as advice is that it takes something away and gives nothing back.

The lesson inside the book: change what you're measuring against

In Focused Silver, Marianna is midway through training Silver in the superpower of focus when she moves on to the skill that quietly protects all the others. She tells him that another thing superheroes master is not comparing themselves to other people, and then she gives him the replacement:

"Don't worry about what anyone else can do. Just compare yourself to who you were yesterday. Keep getting a little better each day, and you'll become a superhero."

Read it twice and you'll see what she has actually done. She hasn't asked Silver to stop measuring himself, which is a thing no child can do on command. She's handed him a different person to measure against, and it happens to be the only person in the world he is guaranteed to be able to beat: himself, one day ago.

That matters because of where this lands in the story. Just before it, Silver has been sitting in class unable to write a difficult word, saying "I can't do it" and hoping nobody notices. Marianna gives him the word yet. And the example Silver reaches for straight away is a comparison: "So, I can't skateboard, and some other kids can. I should just say I can't skateboard… yet?" That's the wound, right there, in the middle of a lesson about focus. The other kids can. The two ideas are stitched together on purpose. Yet keeps the door open, and compare yourself to yesterday is how a child walks through it without checking over their shoulder every ten seconds to see who is further along.

Why yesterday is a better yardstick

A child who is measuring against the fastest reader in the class has set themselves a target that moves, that they don't control, and that mostly delivers bad news. A child measuring against their own last week has a target that is fair, close enough to reach, and responsive to effort. Practise, and the number moves. Don't, and it doesn't. For a five-year-old, that's the first honest relationship with progress they'll ever have.

It also, usefully, gets a child back to work. Comparison eats attention. The child watching the next desk isn't focusing on their own page, which is the whole point of the training Silver is doing. Marianna is protecting the mission.

“Instead of saying 'I can't', add the magical word 'yet'.”

Focused Silver is a superhero training story that teaches your child the skills behind focus one day at a time, including the one that stops them measuring their worth against the child at the next desk. For ages 3 to 7.

View Focused Silver on Amazon

What research suggests about all this

Marianna's instinct has a long history behind it. Back in 1954, the psychologist Leon Festinger set out what he called social comparison theory: the idea that people work out how they're doing by measuring themselves against others, and that they lean on this most when no objective yardstick is available. Which is a fair description of being small. A child has no reliable way to know whether their reading is "good". All they have is the person sitting next to them.

What's less well known is that psychologists also describe the alternative Marianna reaches for. In 1977, Stuart Albert proposed temporal comparison theory in the journal Psychological Review: the same comparing instinct, but pointed at yourself across time rather than at other people. Present you, measured against past you. Research since has treated both as ordinary parts of how we build a sense of how we're doing, and being offered the second one gives a child somewhere to look that isn't sideways.

And the yet that sits beside it is Carol Dweck's territory: her work on what she calls a growth mindset suggests that children who see ability as something that grows with effort tend to respond to difficulty by trying differently, rather than concluding they're simply not a person who can do this. "I can't skateboard yet" and "I'm better than I was last month" are the same belief said two ways. Neither of them requires anybody else to do worse.

How to use it at home

1. Don't argue with the comparison. Move it.

When your child says Sophie is better at reading, resist "no she isn't" and resist "that doesn't matter". Both are answers to a question they didn't ask. Try: "Maybe. What could you read at Christmas?" Then wait. Let them work out the gap themselves, because a child who finds their own progress believes it, and a child who is told about it files it under things parents say.

2. Make yesterday's self visible

Small children have almost no memory for how bad they used to be at things, which robs them of the evidence. So keep some. An old drawing in a drawer, a video of a wobbly first attempt at the monkey bars, last term's reading book left on the shelf. Marianna's rule only works if yesterday is something a child can actually look at.

3. Praise the gap, not the position

"You did fifteen and last week you could only do eight" beats "you're brilliant at this", and it beats "you're the best in your group" by a mile, because the day your child stops being the best in the group, that praise turns into a problem. Progress is the thing you want them proud of, since progress is the only part they own.

4. Add the word yet, out loud, every time

"I can't do it" gets one word bolted on the end, and you say it lightly, not as a correction. It's a small linguistic habit that keeps a child in the game long enough for practice to do its work.

5. Watch your own comparing

Children copy the yardstick they see us using. If they hear us measuring ourselves against other parents, or measuring them against a sibling or a cousin, then "compare yourself to who you were yesterday" is a rule that applies to them and not to the household. That doesn't hold for long.

The bigger picture

Comparing is not a childhood problem you can solve and be done with. It follows people into work, into parenting, into the scroll before bed. What a child can be given at five is a second place to look, and the habit of looking there first. Focused Silver hands them that in one sentence from a woman training a pup: don't worry about what anyone else can do, just compare yourself to who you were yesterday. It sounds like a small thing. It is, in the way that a rudder is small.

There's more of Marianna's training in the power of "yet", which pairs directly with this lesson, and in how Focused Silver teaches kids to focus. You can meet Silver and Marianna in a free sample of Focused Silver. This article is part of our bigger guide to helping your child focus and learn, and if you're building a focus bookshelf, start with the best children's books to help kids focus.