Which math games are worth it in fifth grade? Short answer: the ones aimed at one named skill. Mine are a closest-to-one card game for adding unlike fractions, and a half-a-recipe round in the kitchen for multiplying them. Then a box of sugar cubes for volume, a thousandths round for reading decimals, and a sharing game where you divide by a two-digit number.

What fifth grade math actually asks for

I read the standards myself before buying anything. In fifth grade that saved me from practicing the wrong half of the year. The new work is in fractions. Children should “Add and subtract fractions with unlike denominators”, mixed numbers included, by swapping them for equal fractions that do match. The standard shows its own worked example, that “2/3 + 5/4 = 8/12 + 15/12 = 23/12”. Read that slowly and you can see the shape of the trouble. Nothing in it is hard on its own, and there are three places to lose your footing.

The same part of the standards asks for something I had not expected. Children have to guess the answer before they work it out. They should “Use benchmark fractions and number sense of fractions to estimate mentally”. The example the standard picks is to “recognize an incorrect result 2/5 + 1/2 = 3/7, by observing that 3/7 < 1/2”. That one line changed what I ask at the table. Before the answer, I ask whether it will be more or less than a half. A child who can say that will catch their own mistakes for the rest of the year.

Fractions then get multiplied and divided. Fifth graders “multiply a fraction or whole number by a fraction”. The standard shows “(2/3) × 4 = 8/3” and asks children to “create a story context for this equation”. They divide too, but only in the easier direction. They “divide unit fractions by whole numbers and whole numbers by unit fractions”, and the page works through why “4 ÷ (1/5) = 20 because 20 × (1/5) = 4”. A footnote says plainly that “division of a fraction by a fraction is not a requirement at this grade”. That is worth knowing before you set a child a question nobody expects them to do yet.

Decimals go one place further right. Children “Read, write, and compare decimals to thousandths”. That takes in expanded form, which the standard writes out as “347.392 = 3 × 100 + 4 × 10 + 7 × 1 + 3 × (1/10) + 9 × (1/100) + 2 × (1/1000)”. They compare two of them “based on meanings of the digits in each place”, using the greater than, equals and less than signs. They round them to any place. And they “Add, subtract, multiply, and divide decimals to hundredths”. The thousandths column is the new part. In my experience it is also where a child who was fine with money suddenly is not.

The written methods arrive the same year. Fifth graders “Fluently multiply multi-digit whole numbers using the standard algorithm”. They also find whole-number quotients “with up to four-digit dividends and two-digit divisors”. The divisor is the number you are dividing by, and a two-digit one is the jump from fourth grade. Volume feels like a relief after all that, because it is physical. Children apply “the formulas V = l × w × h and V = b × h for rectangular prisms”, and learn to “Recognize volume as additive”. Two smaller jobs sit alongside. Children use “parentheses, brackets, or braces in numerical expressions”, so that “add 8 and 7, then multiply by 2” gets written as “2 × (8 + 7)”. And they swap units inside one system, which the standard shows as “convert 5 cm to 0.05 m”.

Why fractions are the skill to protect this year

If you only have the energy to guard one thing, guard fractions. Division sits just behind it. In 2012 Robert Siegler and colleagues published a study in Psychological Science, using large national data sets from the United States and the United Kingdom. They reported that a child's “knowledge of fractions and of division uniquely predicts” their “knowledge of algebra and overall mathematics achievement in high school, 5 or 6 years later”. The link held after they allowed for other math knowledge, general ability, working memory, and family income and education.

A prediction is not a promise, and one study settles nothing on its own. What it changed for me was smaller than that. When a fractions week goes badly I slow that week down instead of pushing through, because the same ground comes back every year after it. Volume can wait until next month if it has to. Fractions cannot.

The five questions that show you where to start

I would ask these before downloading anything, because the answers change what you pick. One question per skill, on a blank page, sitting next to your child. Watch how they answer rather than whether they get it right.

1. Write 1/2 + 1/3. Ask, before they work it out, whether the answer comes in under one or over it.

What you are listening for is the guess rather than the sum. A child who cannot say which side of one it lands on is going to add the tops and the bottoms at some point this year. The standard's own example of a wrong answer is exactly that kind of slip.

2. Ask: what is 1/2 of 2/3?

Listen for whether the answer gets smaller. Multiplying by something less than one makes things smaller. That is the idea my own child spent the longest quietly fighting.

3. Ask them to write seven tenths, seven hundredths and seventy thousandths as decimals, then put the three in order.

What I listen for is whether my child is reading the columns or just the digits.

4. Write nine hundred and sixty-two divided by twenty-six.

Watch the first step rather than the answer. The question is whether they can guess how many twenty-sixes fit, because that guess is the whole method. Hesitating on twenty-six times three is a times tables problem wearing a long division costume.

5. Ask: how many sugar cubes fit in a box four cubes long, three wide and two deep?

A child who multiplies all three has the formula. A child who multiplies only two of them has the area of the base, and has stopped one step early. That is the most common answer I have heard at our table.

Whichever one wobbled is the game you play tonight. The other four can wait a week.

Five games, one per skill

I have never printed anything for these. I use a deck of cards with the face cards taken out and aces counting as one, a measuring cup, and a box of sugar cubes.

Closest to one, for adding fractions with unlike denominators

Deal four cards each. Make two fractions out of them, add the two together, and whoever lands closest to one wins the round. Going over is allowed. Before anyone works anything out, we each say out loud whether our total will come in under one or over it. Getting that call right is worth a point on its own in our house.

The saying-it-first part is the whole reason I like this one. The arithmetic is the standard's “replacing given fractions with equivalent fractions”, and that gets practiced either way. Guessing first is the thing a worksheet never asks for, and it is the habit that catches a wrong answer before it gets written down.

Half a recipe, for multiplying fractions

Pick something you actually cook and halve it out loud, with your child holding the cup. Two-thirds of a cup becomes a third. Three-quarters becomes three-eighths, which is where it stops being obvious and starts being the lesson. We do it the other way round too, making more of the recipe rather than less. So multiplying by more than one and by less than one both happen at the same counter.

Fifth grade asks children to “create a story context” for an equation like “(2/3) × 4”. A recipe is the story context sitting on your counter already. What I notice is that a child who has poured three-eighths of a cup stops arguing that multiplying should make numbers bigger.

The box game, for volume

Find a small box and a bag of sugar cubes. Guess how many fit, fill it, and count them. Then work the answer out again with the formula and see which guess was closer. Once that is easy, tape two boxes together and do it again. “Recognize volume as additive” is in the standard, and a taped pair of boxes is what it means.

This is the one my own child asks to play, and I think it is because she can check the answer without me. The cubes either fit or they do not. I would keep this one for the evenings when the fractions have gone badly and the table needs a win.

Thousandths war, for reading and comparing decimals

Deal three cards each and make a decimal with them, a digit each in tenths, hundredths and thousandths. Bigger number takes the pair. Say the number out loud in full, three hundred and ninety-two thousandths rather than a string of digits, because the long way round is where the columns live. Then play a round for the smallest, which is harder than it sounds.

Every so often I write a round down the way the standard does, in the form that reads “3 × (1/10) + 9 × (1/100) + 2 × (1/1000)”, and we read it back. That is the version that fixes the seven tenths against seven hundredths problem. I have never found a quicker way to fix it.

Twenty-six shares, for dividing by a two-digit number

Deal four cards to make a big number, then two more to make the number you will divide it by. Race each other to the nearest whole number rather than the exact answer. Pencil and paper allowed. First to say roughly how many times the small number goes into the big one, and be close, wins the round.

Guessing first is the part fifth grade actually needs. The standard wants answers to sums “with up to four-digit dividends and two-digit divisors”, worked out “using strategies based on place value” and on “the relationship between multiplication and division”. If the tables underneath are shaky, that will show up here before anywhere else, and my guide to math fact practice games has the order I would work through them in.

Why spread-out practice is the part that sticks

The thing I got wrong for about a year was treating practice as a quantity. An hour on Sunday felt like it should be worth six ten-minute goes. As far as I can tell it is not. In a 2008 study in Psychological Science, Nicholas Cepeda and colleagues taught “more than 1,350 individuals” a set of facts. They brought them back for a review after a gap, then tested them again later. Widening the gap between the two sessions helped the final score at first, and then started to hurt it. Their closing line is blunt: “The interaction of gap and test delay implies that many educational practices are highly inefficient”.

The second thing is what happens inside the ten minutes. Reading a worked example again is not the same as being asked. Henry Roediger and Jeffrey Karpicke, writing in Psychological Science in 2006, had students either re-read prose passages or sit short recall tests on them. On the later tests, “prior testing produced substantially greater retention than studying”, even though the re-reading made students more sure they would remember. Their summary is the sentence I keep coming back to: “Testing is a powerful means of improving learning, not just assessing it”. The research is about prose rather than fractions, so I hold it as a principle rather than a promise. It still points one way, which is to ask your child for the answer rather than show it to them and hope.

In practice it changed how we practice at home. We come back tomorrow rather than stay tonight, and I make my child produce the answer rather than follow mine. Those are the two ideas our own math games are built around, and how our math games teach walks through the mechanics.

The worksheet that came home

The five games above practice whichever skill I picked. The page the teacher sent home is a different job. In a normal school week it is the one I would do first, because it is the exact thing your child got wrong on Tuesday. I do it with a pen. I take a handful of questions off the sheet, change the numbers, and write them out again. It works, and it does not take long. I wrote that out step by step in turning tonight's homework into a game.

When a game is not the answer

A game is practice, and practice assumes the method landed. In fifth grade the thing I would check first is the times tables. What I see at our kitchen table is that both of this year's written methods keep asking for them, multiplying down a column and then dividing back the other way. A child still working those out is carrying a load before the new skill even starts. If that is where you are, I would drop back a rung to my guide to math games for 4th graders. If the decimal columns are the problem rather than the arithmetic, I would go to my guide to place value games instead.

Fifth grade is also late enough that a child may have already decided math is a thing they are bad at. I would take that more seriously than a gap in the skills. More questions tend to confirm the idea rather than shift it. What we did was shrink the session down to things that were already easy, and stay there until math stopped feeling horrible. That won back more than pushing on would have. Trouble that has run all year is worth a conversation with the teacher. If something feels more stubborn than practice, I set out what I would ask for in my guide to the signs to look for when numbers are unusually hard. Once things are moving, I wrote up the rhythm we settled into in my guide to math practice games.

Frequently asked questions

What math should a 5th grader know?

The standards ask fifth graders to “Add and subtract fractions with unlike denominators”, mixed numbers included, to “multiply a fraction or whole number by a fraction”, and to “divide unit fractions by whole numbers and whole numbers by unit fractions”. They “Read, write, and compare decimals to thousandths”, round decimals to any place, and “Add, subtract, multiply, and divide decimals to hundredths”. They “Fluently multiply multi-digit whole numbers using the standard algorithm” and find quotients “with up to four-digit dividends and two-digit divisors”. They apply “the formulas V = l × w × h and V = b × h for rectangular prisms”. And they use “parentheses, brackets, or braces in numerical expressions” and swap units inside one measurement system.

What are good math games for 5th graders to play at home?

Good ones are aimed at a single named skill. The ones we play at home are a closest-to-one card game for adding fractions with unlike denominators, a half-a-recipe round in the kitchen for multiplying fractions, a box-filling game with sugar cubes for volume, a thousandths round for reading decimals, and a sharing game where you divide by a two-digit number.

Why does my 5th grader suddenly find fractions hard?

Because this is the year the bottom numbers stop matching. Fourth grade compares fractions. Fifth grade asks children to add and subtract them with unlike denominators, which means rewriting both fractions before the adding even starts. My view is that the trouble I see at home is in that rewriting step rather than in the arithmetic. The fix is practice at guessing the answer first. That is what the standard itself asks for when it wants children to “recognize an incorrect result 2/5 + 1/2 = 3/7, by observing that 3/7 < 1/2”.

How long should a fifth grader practice math for?

In our house it is one short go after dinner rather than a long session at the weekend. Research on the spacing of study sessions points the same way. In a 2008 study in Psychological Science, Nicholas Cepeda and colleagues taught “more than 1,350 individuals” a set of facts. They found that the gap between sessions changed how much stuck, and concluded that “The interaction of gap and test delay implies that many educational practices are highly inefficient”. So I would rather come back to a skill again tomorrow than sit with it all evening tonight.

Are fractions in 5th grade worth putting first?

If something has to give, I would protect fractions and division. Robert Siegler and colleagues, writing in Psychological Science in 2012, reported that a child's “knowledge of fractions and of division uniquely predicts” their “knowledge of algebra and overall mathematics achievement in high school, 5 or 6 years later”. The link held after they allowed for other math knowledge, general ability, working memory, and family income and education. That is a prediction rather than a promise. It is still a good reason to slow down on a bad fractions week instead of pushing through it.

My 5th grader is behind in math. Where do I start?

Lower down than the homework suggests. Fifth grade asks children to “Fluently multiply multi-digit whole numbers using the standard algorithm” and to divide by two-digit numbers. Both lean on the times tables several times in a row, so a child still working those out is carrying a load before the new skill starts. I would check that rung first. Tell the teacher what you are doing at home, and keep the sessions short enough that your child finishes them.