Which subtraction games are worth playing? Short answer: the ones that practice a single rung instead of subtraction in general. Ours are a take-away round on fingers, a how-many-more-to-ten round with cards, a count-back-or-count-up race on a die, a flip-the-fact round on two dice, a down-through-ten round in an empty egg box, and a find-the-missing-number round on a scrap of paper.

The order subtraction arrives in

I read the kindergarten through second grade standards before I picked a single game. Subtraction arrives bolted to addition, one pairing at a time, and each pairing asks a child for something different.

It starts physical. Kindergarteners “Represent addition and subtraction with objects, fingers, mental images, drawings, sounds (e.g., claps), acting out situations, verbal explanations, expressions, or equations”. The fluency asked for that year is deliberately small: “Fluently add and subtract within 5”. Next to it sits the word problem version, where children “Solve addition and subtraction word problems, and add and subtract within 10”. So if your child is in that year, claps and raisins are not a soft option. They are what the year asks for.

Then comes the rung I would protect ahead of all the others, because it changes what the word even means. First graders have to “Understand subtraction as an unknown-addend problem”. An addend is simply a number you add on, so the standard is asking a child to work out what was added rather than what was taken away. Its own example is to “subtract 10 - 8 by finding the number that makes 10 when added to 8”. A child who can do that has stopped taking away, as I read it, and started asking how far it is from one number up to the other. That is the move I have watched turn the hard questions into easy ones. It also explains why the pairs that make ten matter so much, since kindergarten already asks children to “find the number that makes 10 when added to the given number”.

First grade then names its strategies out loud. Children “Add and subtract within 20, demonstrating fluency for addition and subtraction within 10”, and the two I lean on at home are going down through a ten, written out as “13 - 4 = 13 - 3 - 1 = 10 - 1 = 9”, and using the link between the two operations, as in “knowing that 8 + 4 = 12, one knows 12 - 8 = 4”. Counting gets a line of its own too. Children “Relate counting to addition and subtraction (e.g., by counting on 2 to add 2)”.

One more first grade rung caught us out completely. Children have to “Determine the unknown whole number in an addition or subtraction equation relating three whole numbers”, judging lines like “8 + ? = 11, 5 = _ - 3, 6 + 6 = _”. The middle one is the troublemaker. My child could answer any subtraction written the usual way round, then stall completely once the gap moved to the front. That told me the answers were coming from a pattern rather than from the idea underneath. The word problem standard flags the same thing, asking for situations “involving situations of adding to, taking from, putting together, taking apart, and comparing, with unknowns in all positions”.

Second grade wants the small ones automatic and the big ones organized. Children “Fluently add and subtract within 20 using mental strategies”, and then “Fluently add and subtract within 100 using strategies based on place value, properties of operations, and/or the relationship between addition and subtraction”. That last phrase is the same add-on idea again, back for bigger numbers. The same year asks children to “Mentally add 10 or 100 to a given number 100-900, and mentally subtract 10 or 100 from a given number 100-900”. It looks like a parlor trick. To my mind it is the thing that makes bigger subtraction feel doable in a child's head.

The ten minutes I would spend tonight

Four short rounds, in this order

Here is what a weeknight go looks like for us. It fits between dinner and the bath. Sit beside your child, not opposite them, and ask the questions out loud instead of writing them down.

1. Open a rung below tonight's target.

If tonight is going down through a ten, open with take-aways inside five. You are not really practicing. You are buying the look on a child's face when the first question goes well.

2. Spend most of the time on one named rung, as a game.

One rung, not three. Pick whichever game below matches it, and play until it gets boring. In our house that comes sooner than I ever expect. While we play I keep a note in my head of which questions got counted out on fingers and which ones simply arrived, because the gap between those two is the next target.

3. Ask for two or three they got wrong yesterday.

Cold, with no warm-up. If the answer does not come, say it yourself and move on. A wrong one coming back a day later is worth more to me than a brand new question, and the round is over in a minute.

4. Stop while it is still going well.

This is the bit I get wrong most often. Our worst evenings were the ones I kept going precisely because they were going so nicely.

Six subtraction games, one per rung

I have never printed anything for these. Our kit is whatever was already in the kitchen: a deck of cards with the picture cards taken out and aces counting as one, a pair of dice, an empty egg box, a scrap of paper.

Take it away on fingers, for the smallest ones

I hold up some fingers and ask my child to count them, fold a few down behind my hand, then ask how many are left. Then we swap over and they set the question. When mine wanted noise instead we clapped it: a run of loud claps, a couple of quiet ones after them, and the question was how many of the loud ones there had been.

This is the rung the standards open on, and the list of ways to do it is generous: “objects, fingers, mental images, drawings, sounds (e.g., claps), acting out situations, verbal explanations, expressions, or equations”. The target for the whole year is only to “Fluently add and subtract within 5”, so I keep the numbers tiny and ignore my own urge to push past it. If your child is working below this, I would go to math games for kindergarten instead.

How many more to ten, with cards

Turn over one card. Ask how many more it needs to reach ten. Keep the slow ones in a pile of their own, and once the quick ones are automatic, play a round using only that pile.

I would build this rung before any of the others, because the standards hang subtraction on it. First graders are asked to “Understand subtraction as an unknown-addend problem”, with the example of subtracting “10 - 8 by finding the number that makes 10 when added to 8”, and kindergarten has already asked children to “find the number that makes 10 when added to the given number”. Once that pairing is solid, say the subtraction version straight after the addition one. Your child gets to hear that ten take away eight is a question they answered a second ago.

Count back or count up, on one die

We turn over a card, roll a die, and count back that many from the card. The counting happens out loud, and it starts at the card rather than at one. Then we play the other half, dealing a pair of cards and racing to say how far it is from the smaller one up to the bigger one.

Both halves are counting, which the standard treats as the bridge into both operations: “Relate counting to addition and subtraction (e.g., by counting on 2 to add 2)”. The part I find interesting is making your child choose. Ask which direction was quicker for the pair in front of them. After a week of asking, mine started picking counting up whenever the two numbers sat close together, and I would take that choice over any amount of speed.

Flip the fact, on two dice

We roll a pair of dice, add them out loud, then say the subtractions hiding in the same numbers. The standard's own example will do: “knowing that 8 + 4 = 12, one knows 12 - 8 = 4”. I keep going until mine says the later lines before I ask for them.

The standard names this one as using “the relationship between addition and subtraction (e.g., knowing that 8 + 4 = 12, one knows 12 - 8 = 4)”. It is the cheapest rung on my list, because that line hands you the subtraction off the back of an addition fact your child already knows by heart. If the addition side is the thin part, I would go at addition games first, then math fact practice games.

Down through ten, in an empty egg box

We tape over the spare cups of an egg box so that a row of ten is left, fill it with counters, raisins are fine, and put a few loose ones on the table beside it. Then I ask for the one the standard writes out, thirteen take away four. The loose ones go first, and only then does the box open.

Stopping at the ten before carrying on is the part I would not skip. The standard writes the method out in full as “13 - 4 = 13 - 3 - 1 = 10 - 1 = 9”, and a box with loose counters next to it turns that line into something a child can see instead of something they have to take on trust. Once it is going well, turn the box away so they have to picture it.

Find the missing number, on a scrap of paper

Write a line with a gap in it and ask what belongs in the gap. Then swap over and let your child write one to catch you out, which is the half mine wanted to keep doing. Move the gap around on purpose, including to the front of the line.

Take the lines from the standard itself, which asks children to “Determine the unknown whole number in an addition or subtraction equation relating three whole numbers” and offers “8 + ? = 11, 5 = _ - 3, 6 + 6 = _”. Watch what happens on the middle one. A child who objects that it is written backwards is telling you what they think the equal sign means, and that is worth half an evening of your time. The word problem standard asks for the same flexibility, with “unknowns in all positions”.

When borrowing is the part that breaks

Every time another parent has told me subtraction is going badly, it has turned out to be the written method with the crossings out rather than the facts: a child who gets it right on Monday and wrong on Thursday. What I would do is stop practicing the method and go at what sits underneath it.

The standards are fairly blunt about what that is. Second graders working on bigger numbers have to “Add and subtract within 1000, using concrete models or drawings and strategies based on place value”, and the standard spells out what the crossings out stand for: “sometimes it is necessary to compose or decompose tens or hundreds”. There is even a standard for being able to say why the method works, asking children to “Explain why addition and subtraction strategies work, using place value and the properties of operations”.

So I would leave the layout alone and practice what sits under it. Start with jumping in tens, out loud, with no paper. That is the standard asking children to “Mentally add 10 or 100 to a given number 100-900, and mentally subtract 10 or 100 from a given number 100-900”. In a shop I point at a price and ask for ten less than it, then a hundred less, which is that standard with a price tag instead of a worksheet. I stop after a couple. Then place value, meaning what each digit in a number is worth, because a child who cannot say that has nothing to decompose. For that I would go to place value games, and math games for 2nd graders for the rest of that year.

Why short, spread-out practice is the part that sticks

I used to think of practice as a quantity, and a long Sunday session felt like it should beat a few short goes in the week. As far as I can tell, it does not. In a 2008 study in Psychological Science, Nicholas Cepeda and colleagues taught “more than 1,350 individuals” a set of facts. They brought everyone back for a second session after a gap, then tested them again later on. Widening that gap raised the final score up to a point, after which it started to hurt. Their closing line is blunt: “The interaction of gap and test delay implies that many educational practices are highly inefficient”.

How you fill those few minutes matters as well. Being asked a question is not the same as being shown the answer. Henry Roediger and Jeffrey Karpicke, writing in Psychological Science in 2006, had students either re-read prose passages or sit short recall tests on them. On the later tests “prior testing produced substantially greater retention than studying”, even though re-reading had left them feeling more confident about it. Their summary is the line I keep coming back to: “Testing is a powerful means of improving learning, not just assessing it”. I treat that as a principle rather than a promise about my own child. It still points one way, which is to ask for the answer rather than walk them through mine.

Those two ideas shaped our evenings, and they shaped the math games we built. Come back tomorrow rather than stay tonight, and let the child produce the answer instead of following yours. More on that: how our math games teach.

The worksheet that came home

The games above practice whichever rung I picked for the evening. The sheet the teacher sent home is a different job, and in a normal school week I would do that one first. My method is a pen: take a few questions off the sheet, change the numbers, and write them out again next to the originals. It is quick and it works well enough. Step by step: turning tonight's homework into a game.

When a game is not the answer

A game is practice, and practice only pays off once the idea has landed. With subtraction, the first thing I would check is whether your child can count backwards at all. If your child rattles off numbers going up and stalls going down, I would put the problem below subtraction rather than inside it, and start again at math games for kindergarten. If the counting is solid and the facts are just slow to arrive, the year pages I would try next are math games for 1st graders and math games for 3rd graders.

Watch how your child feels about it as well. What I have seen is that once a child decides they are bad at math, every wrong answer reads to them as proof of it, and more questions confirmed the idea here rather than shifting it. What worked here was shrinking the session right down to questions that were already easy, and staying there until math stopped feeling horrible. Trouble that has run all year is worth raising with the teacher. If something feels more stubborn than practice, I would read the signs worth checking when numbers are unusually hard before the internet at midnight, then come back to our usual math practice games once things are moving.

Frequently asked questions

What are good subtraction games for kids to play at home?

Good ones go at a single rung rather than at subtraction in general. The ones we play are taking away on fingers, how many more to ten with cards, counting back or counting up on a die, flipping the fact on dice, going down through a ten in an empty egg box, and finding the missing number on a scrap of paper.

Why is subtraction harder than addition for my child?

Because it asks for two different moves, and mine had only one of them for a long time. Taking away goes backwards, which I find is slower and easier to lose track of. The faster route is to treat the question as a forwards one, and that move is a named standard: first graders should “Understand subtraction as an unknown-addend problem”, as in subtracting “10 - 8 by finding the number that makes 10 when added to 8”. My reading is that a child who counts backwards for everything is missing that second move rather than being slow.

In what order should a child learn subtraction?

Here is the order I use at home. Start where kindergarten starts, with “Fluently add and subtract within 5” on fingers and objects. Then the pairs that make ten, then subtraction as a missing addend, then the two strategies first grade names: going down through a ten, written out as “13 - 4 = 13 - 3 - 1 = 10 - 1 = 9”, and leaning on addition, as in “knowing that 8 + 4 = 12, one knows 12 - 8 = 4”. Bigger numbers came after all of that here.

When should a child know subtraction facts from memory?

The standards ask second graders to “Fluently add and subtract within 20 using mental strategies”, and the memory line they name explicitly covers addition: “By end of Grade 2, know from memory all sums of two one-digit numbers”. The standard's own example runs the link the other way, that “knowing that 8 + 4 = 12, one knows 12 - 8 = 4”, so what I practice is the sums plus the flip-the-fact habit rather than a separate subtraction list. First grade asks for less, only to “Add and subtract within 20, demonstrating fluency for addition and subtraction within 10”.

My child cannot do borrowing. What should we practice?

Not the written method, in my view, but what sits underneath it. Start with jumping in tens with no paper, which second graders are asked to do: “Mentally add 10 or 100 to a given number 100-900, and mentally subtract 10 or 100 from a given number 100-900”. The second is place value, meaning what each digit in a number is worth. The crossings out stand for the moment when “sometimes it is necessary to compose or decompose tens or hundreds”, and a child who cannot say what a digit is worth has nothing to decompose.

How long should we practice subtraction for?

In our house it is one short go on a weekday evening rather than a long session at the weekend. In a 2008 study in Psychological Science, Nicholas Cepeda and colleagues taught “more than 1,350 individuals” a set of facts and found that the gap between sessions changed how much stuck, concluding that “The interaction of gap and test delay implies that many educational practices are highly inefficient”. So I would rather come back tomorrow than push on tonight.